Just saw the movie and the letter thread

[potioncat]

> > Carol responds:
> > I'm not sure whether it's fair for me to chime in here since I'm 
not a
> > Sirius fan, but I don't think that Gary Oldman is sexy, either. 
> <snip>
>  
> > Anyway, give me Snape in any shape or form and Rickman over 
Oldman,
> > but that's just me.

Potioncat:
I agree! (and I'm the one who started this thread.) It was Sirius's 
hair. I loved his hair.
> 
> 
> Annemehr:
> J.a.s.o.n. I.s.a.a.c.s.  Which is why I was *seriously* 
disappointed 
> that in the big fight scene they spent most of their time as vapor.
> 
> Oldman and Sirius do nothing for me.  I did like Rickman in the 
first 
> movie, but since then he's just looked doughey and has had no 
intensity.
> 
> Annemehr,
> who thinks Lucius Malfoy is slime but would take Jason in his wig 
and 
> leather any day

Potioncat:
Yes, yes and yes. Isaacs was serious eye-candy. I'm sorry he'll have 
to be such a cringing character in DH---unless of course they re-
write his scenes for the movie.

It's really odd about Rickman!Snape, because Rickman doesn't look bad 
in his other movies.