leaky podcast
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Wed Dec 19 21:00:07 UTC 2007
> bboyminn:
>
> Yes, I listened to it; it was very informative, but fair
> warning to those who freaked out when she said Dumbledore
> was gay, don't listen if you don't want to her.
Alla:
Um, not me LOL. Too bad I cannot listen to it, sigh, have to wait for
transcript. I am sooo nervous about installing new things on my
computer.
> At one point, JKR even says of a point she made that fans
> are free to disagree.
Alla:
I feel bad that she even felt a need to make a statement like that.
To me it was always - DUH. Of course we can disagree and I certainly
disagree with her on some of the statements she made or just ignore
them. I never understood why it is so hard to do that. ( Not trying
to start a fight or anything, but it is how I honestly feel. It was
always so easy for me to do and it is hard for me to see how it is
not so easy for all people).
I mean, I am happily ignoring her statement about Harry being a
better godfather than Sirius, because I am yet to see more apple and
oranges comparison.
I threw out of my mental window the statement of Lily's sacrifice
being somehow more significant than James'.
I really really do not buy " we should love DD thing", etc.
I mean, I guess I understand how you cannot completely forget what
she says, like even though I am disagreeing or ignoring those
statements, I still remember that she said them.
BUT to me it is like they exist in another dimension, they do not
cloud the mental picture of canon I have in my head, if that makes
sense.
If I feel her interview statement is consistent with what's in the
book and what's in my head, I add it, if not, I am not, hehe.
Steve:
<SNIP>
> I found it interesting and enjoyable because you really get
> to see JKR's playful personality shine through.
Alla:
I know, I enjoy listening to her talk as well.
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive