Snape's birthday...will she or won't she?

[Cairie Witter]

Just one question please.

Where can you find the birthday list?

Cairie

>>> "dumbledore11214" <dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com> 2007-01-10 02:15 >>>

> > Alla:
> > 
> > Oh, well. Too bad if you ask me ;)
> > 
> > I can always comfort myself that she wishes Happy birthday to 
the 
> > characters who survive and that Snape will be celebrating his 
> > birthdays in Azkaban once the war is ended.
> >

Snape's Witch: 
> Perhaps not, Alla!  ;-)
> 
> It seems to me that Jo is thinking in terms of 2007, so Snape 
might 
> have completed his time in Azkaban and is indeed having a Happy 
> Birthday this day in 2007!!!! 

Alla:

Oh, I agree that she is thinking in terms of 2007, absolutely ;)

I was just hoping that his time in Azkaban would be, you know - 
forever and ever. Dementors to me is metaphor of such horrible 
imaginery, that I would not wish it even on Snape, but I am 
certainly not adverse to Snape having normal nightmares every night 
of his stay in Azkaban, say seeing Lily and James and of course very 
dead Dumbledore. Yep, very suitable to me. 


> As to why Snape is on the list to begin with -- the other three 
heads 
> of house are also on the list so it would look odd for Snape to be 
> left off.  On the other hand it could be said that the other three 
> were added so we wouldn't automatically think Snape was DDM if we 
> assume that everybody else on the list is DDM!  
> 
> Even more interesting is why she added Draco just before HBP was 
> published.
> 
> Snape's Witch
>

Alla:

Totally, it can be a possibility about three heads of the houses as 
you are saying, but actually I was quite serious when I was 
speculating that the characters that are going to survive are on the
list ( obviously I was not the one who thought about it, but I like 
it).

I mean, yes, she does not seem to wish Happy Birthday to Bella, 
Lucius, etc - so the possibility is there that she wishes Happy 
Birthday to good characters and at some point I thought that way 
too, but to me it is also plausible that Bella, Lucius, etc would 
also end up dead at the end, so not only they are bad, they are also 
dead in 2007, if it makes sense.

Oh, and Draco to me makes perfect sense, if she was thinking of the 
future, I cannot stand him, but after HBP he can certainly take 
redemptive route IMO.