Folk in Europe and America: punctuation in quotations?

Dina Lerret bunniqula at gmail.com
Tue Jun 26 15:59:40 UTC 2007


As a follow-up to the whole 'make your post legible' bit, I'm noticing
a trend in fanfic where writers aren't including 'concluding'
punctuation like a comma or period.  I've seen exclamation and
question marks, but the commas and periods are disappearing.  This
tendency is more prevalent among European fans, including the UK.  For
example, a UK fanfic writer, Annie:
[[
"Hey" Jensen opened one eye and grabbed the hand stroking his face
"You are looking better"
]]

It's not just her; I'm encountering this among a variety of writers.
She uses periods and commas elsewhere but not in quotations.  I know
grammar differs in various countries and America may have its own
'bastardized' version of English, but I thought, at least, the UK
didn't completely drop commas and periods in their quotes?  Is this
trait something new or something older?  I was in high school during
the early to mid 90s and that was the last of my formal education
(college dropout).

I'm asking because I proofread over fics--you could say I'm a 'fic
intake' person for a site, which is ironic considered I nearly failed
grammar in school--and I do begin to wonder about these things.  It's
possible to say humans are lemmings by nature: we're taught to follow
by example.  So, if readers see writers drop punctuation and then they
become writers, it's likely some of them will pick up that habit as
well.

Dina




More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive