Umbridge / Blaise's mother / evil author / Snape

[dumbledore11214]

> Catlady:
> I don't think mind reading has anything to do with the opinion
> that people who deliberately spread evil messages are evil
> people regardless of how polite or whatever they are in person. 
<SNIP>

Mike:
Was your first paragraph your example of how JKR was spreading an
evil message? Because, if that's your basis for this last sentence,
I guess I'm missing the connection (to say the least). So here's
mundane me stuck on the notion that anyone that calls JKR herself
evil has jumped off the diving board before checking if the pool
had water in it.
 <SNIP>

Alla:

Heeee, me too Mike, but without reading Catlady's mind ;) I would 
like to venture a guess ( and I could be wrong) that she may  have 
wanted us to find holes indeed in this hypothetical justification 
for calling JKR's evil.

I could be wrong as I said, but here is mine, Catlady :)

I do not think that even if what you described may count as evil 
message, I do not think it follows  that JKR deliberately spreads 
them, tee hee.

Something put in the story on purpose does not equal deliberately 
spreading it. 

I think it still requires a mind reading to figure out for WHAT 
purpose message was put in the story :)

Alla.