Dark is rising again - final post reread impression

marion11111 marion11111 at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 23 20:08:06 UTC 2007


> Eustace Scrubb:
> > Maybe between now and next week they can change the title again--
> maybe
> > The Seeker: Snakes in a Church. (lol)  That would drop the 
pretense
> > that  it has any serious relation to Cooper's work.
> > 
> > I think it was Alla asked whether Max's treachery had been 
> confirmed.
> >  I'm not sure we'll really know until next week--maybe he does an
> > "Edmund" and turns out OK in the end.
> > 
> ><SNIP>
> 
> 

marion11111:
Love it! Snakes in a church.  And maybe it will be an Edmund-style 
plot - I hope we get Turkish Delight and Father Christmas.


> Alla:
> 
> Now I have another question to ask, the answer to which scares me 
> already.
> 
> Is it confirmed that Walker falls in love with Maggie?
> 
> Because OF COURSE we cannot just leave his treachery be as a 
result 
> of dissapointment in beloved father figure, aren't we?
> 
> That's not exciting enough, not Hollywood like, me thinks.
> 
> NAH, him falling in love with the agent of dark AND losing his 
soul 
> too would be so much COOLER.
> 


marion11111:
Oh, Alla, I think we're way past wine by now.  I thinking 
hallucinogenics are needed.

I read another interview where the director/screenwriter chose to 
make Will American to emphasize his status as an "outsider."  I 
would guess that's also why we see mean siblings and parents.  But 
really, the part that was so interesting about Will is that he is 
perfectly happy as Will.  It's not like Harry Potter where going to 
Hogwarts is the only bright spot in his life.  Will doesn't need to 
be an Old One.  But he has no choice.  He will need to leave his 
family someday and see everyone he loves die.

I suppose they took the storyline where Hawkins is talking to Maggie 
just before he turns to the Dark and made it into a romance.  Blech.

I have no idea why Max needs to be bad.  Double blech.







More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive