HP...The Good or Evil Controversy
Carol
justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 19 16:43:58 UTC 2008
the new Steve wrote:
> Its an interesting theory however, nothing in the first five films
suggests that Harry and Voldy are related. I believe with Harry dead
Voldermolt would then be able to take over the wizardry world. This of
course won't happen.
> Harry will prevail the only question then becomes at what cost?
Cabal responded:
> The movies won't make a connection between Harry and Voldy because
the only scene in HBP where there's a hint to Voldy being a descendent
is not going to be in the film.
>
> But The Deathly Hallows is part of the Tales of Beedle the Bard --
<spoilers belatedly deleted>
>
Carol responds:
Is it fair to our new members (Carol Lynn and the new Steve) to
provide spoilers without a warning? neither of them has read the
books. (I can see providing info from the first five books that wasn't
included in the film versions, but we're ruining the movies for them
by telling them so much.)
To Carol Lynn and new Steve: You're missing out by not reading the
books! The first three might take you all of a week to read. You can
read the entire set in a month or less by reading just a few hours a
night.
Carol, seconding zanooda in suggesting the movie list rather than OT
or the main list for members who haven't read the books and noting
that they'll encounter spoilers even there
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive