[HPFGU-OTChatter] Re: Freaks and Geeks LONG and uncoherent ramble

Lee Kaiwen leekaiwen at yahoo.com
Fri Feb 22 22:49:11 UTC 2008


Kemper:
> My answer would have to be Star Wars: Shadow of the 
 > Empire because it was the most poorly written book

Worse than DaVinci Code? Wow!

Though I won't say DC is the worst book I've *ever* read (Sword of 
Shanarra wins that honor), it's certainly the worst I've read in the 
last quarter century. Two hours of *my* life I'd love to have back.

> Kemper, who believes some books should be burned

As an act of mercy, yes.

Alla:
 > still think movie is the best though.

So in this case the book did not live up to the movie? :-)

CJ, whose only experience with Star Wars literature was the novelization 
of the original movie.





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive