Just Wondering

Steve bboyminn at yahoo.com
Mon Mar 17 18:56:34 UTC 2008


---  "danielle" <drdara at ...> wrote:
>
> I am curious, to whom would Harry give the Maruaders Map too.
> Would it be James Sirius, Albus Severus or little Lily Potter.
> James S may be more like his namesake, but I am thinking he 
> would give it to Albus who is more like Harry. Ginny would 
> prolly (or in English 'Probably') vote for Lily lol. Now if 
> Harry gave over the invisibility cloak to the kids while they
> were attending Hogwarts who do you think he would give it too?
> 
> Danielle
>

bboyminn:

JKR was asked this question, and I tend to agree with her 
answer. She said, that Harry being a responsible adult and
parent would not give the Map or the Cloak to anyone. No
parent could or would sanction, night time wanderings or
mischief making that was against the school rules put in
place to protect students. 

So, Harry kept the Maps safely locked away in his desk. 
Though JKR reckons James Sirius snuck into Harry's study
and took the Map, and used it at Hogwarts. I'm sure Harry at
some point noticed the Maps was gone, and assume, rightly, 
where it had went, but said nothing. 

So, I don't think, being responsible parents, Harry or
Ginny would choose anyone to give the Map to. They would
discourage their kids from mischief making, but at the same
time, know that mischief making was very likely to occur.  

Steve/bluewizard






More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive