[HPFGU-OTChatter] Re: rewriting DH

[Sharon Hayes]

Jayne:

> Why would people want to rewrite DH ?IMHO it was her second best
book
> (OotP was the best ). It tied everything up nicely for me.

Magpie:
She said somebody offered it as a challenge and she took them up on
it. I assume that's why.

It seems the challenge came as a response to the many people who
didn't like it or thought it was poor. Though that doesn't always
lead to wanting to re-write it.

Sharon:
LOL. I love all the books too, but I agree with some others that certain characters didn't get their due in the end. And that Epilogue was atrocious IMHO. It was fun to rewrite. very Carthartic :-)




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]