list of books Sarah Palin wanted removed from the library - sigh

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Sep 8 11:51:48 UTC 2008


 "susanmcgee48176" wrote:
>
> My information was that this was from minutes of the Library..
> 
> I will check further, and get back to you all..

Potioncat:
I'm glad you posted. We are a curious, questioning bunch. If we will 
discuss at great length the meaning of DD's gleam  then we'll really 
chew on something of more importance.

> Kemper now:
 
> The Frontiersman reposted a news article regarding the situation 
from
> 12 years ago.  You can find it here:
> http://tinyurl.com/6adxhj


Potioncat (undecided about the election at this point, so not yet 
supporting either side)

Having read the article, I don't know how Pallin stands on banning 
books. I can picture these questions being asked in this way to test 
the librarian's resolve. So this article doesn't tell me enough to 
decide. It does tell me that some sources have combined stories into 
an inaccurate one. 

As to the list itself. "My Brother Sam is Dead" was required reading 
in my son's 6th grade. It is a miserable, demoralizing book. Took all 
the glory out of war, and brought our deified Revolutionary ancestors 
back to human earth. I recommend it. (But I was glad my younger one 
didn't read it in 6th grade, because I didn't want to go through it 
again.)






More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive