What should we do next?

Jen Reese stevejjen at earthlink.net
Sat Jan 17 16:37:36 UTC 2009


Eggplant:
> I doubt the focus of the main group will ever be on the films, but I
> don't see the need to treat them like a crazy uncle you keep locked up
> in the cellar. Like it or not for virtually all new readers of
> the series their mental images of the scenes in the books will be
> influenced by the movies. There is just no point in pretending
> that a certain invention made in the late part of the nineteenth 
> century doesn't exist.
> 
> In the early days when the book series was far from complete and
> most posts were some variation of "What will happen next?" it
> might have made sense to have two separate lists, but that ship
> has sailed. At least that's what I think. 


Jen: I like this idea.  It's hard to separate the two when you want to 
talk comparison/contrast.  Plus there can be casual talk on OTC for the 
fun stuff, like who was casted, 'can you believe they cut this out?!' 
etc.  

We could use 'Movie' in the header on main; isn't that how it was 
handled prior to a separate list?  Eggplant has a point that everything 
is starting to blend together when it comes to talking about HP because 
there's not all the theorizing.  I picture the lists collapsing down as 
time goes by, more like when hpfgu started.  It's fun to read the back 
posts when everything was mixed up.  I'm sure dividing the lists 
ordered the chaos when there were thousands of posts every month.  
Chaos can be fun though, yes?






More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive