HBP movie related question (SPOILERS)
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 28 02:48:25 UTC 2009
> Jen: I can believe that with all the condensing and reshaping found in the movies. As for the big events, I thought the movie ending of HBP made it obvious Snape was up to something when he killed DD, that there was ambiguity. Then my bro-in-law (movie viewer only) said something like, "So Snape was bad all along; he was just fooling Dumbledore." I'm guessing Snape's use of an AK was the reason why he interpreted the scene that way. IIRC the Unforgiveables aren't presented as ambiguous in the GOF movie.
>
Alla:
You know, meant to tell you, my friend at work told me that her brother in law, also only movie goer reacted same way about Snape, too funny that :-)
I mean, logically I do understand that AK can invoke this thought, hehe, but to me movie Snape, even after AK just does not invoke this intense erm dislike I have for book Snape. Wierd, huh? Oh I do not like him much, since he is supposed to have done all the same things that book Snape did, but to me he just does not carry this negative energy which I feel from book Snape. I know it is wierd.
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive