HBP movie related question (SPOILERS)

[dumbledore11214]

> Jen: It's going both ways for making the characters look better, like Draco not casting the Crucio at Harry in the bathroom and no mention as yet that Snape delivered the prophecy to LV.  Maybe in the DH movie.  Although with what little animosity Harry showed toward Snape after Dumbledore's 'murder' in HBP, why bother ramping up the antagonism between the two in DH?!?

Alla:

Oh yeah, absolutely. That reminded me another huh moment I had. I am sure you know that in the book I did not blame Harry one bit for defending himself from Draco. I mean I wished he did not use Sectusemptra, but  to me it was self-defense, period, end of story, I was not crying about "poor" Draco and would not have been upset if he died, you know? Here, we do not have Draco saying Crucio and Harry just uses Snape's nasty creation and he does not get detention for that?

To me this was sort of bizarre.

Another moment I thought was definitely making character look better when Hermione's birds did not attack Ron, but were just thrown against the wall. 

And yes, agreed, about Snape and Harry's animosity, I doubt it will even work with same intensity if they try to do it in one movie instead of seven.


Jen: 
> You know, I missed Trelawney's role in the HBP movie, reading her cards and prophesying doom on the Lightning Struck Tower.
> 
> I completely agree with you about Tom Felton, Geoff - what a performance.  He was riveting during the death scene & while facing the fate of leaving Hogwarts with his crazy Auntie.  His last look back at the damaged Great Hall said it all.
>

Alla:

I think Tom is amazing, I totally want to see his next projects now.