Ginny

wildirishrose01us wildirishrose at fiber.net
Thu May 7 19:57:02 UTC 2009


--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:
Carol notes:
Absolutely, Ginny's being the youngest and not yet of age has something to do with it. But Molly's line, "Not my daughter, you b----!" does suggest--not that Ginny is less gifted or powerful than her brothers as a Witch rather than a Wizard (after all, look whom Molly is fighting)--but that there's something special to Molly about her only daughter. Ron is right, I think, that Molly (though she loves him dearly) was disappointed that he wasn't born a girl and tried again, one last time, to have a daughter with Ginny, at which point she stopped having children. So Ginny, as the youngest and the only girl, is doubly precious. But, also, setting aside JKR's glaring allusion to a certain film, Molly means, "You've killed my son Fred. You're not going to take my daughter, too." Or that's how I read it.

Marianne:

Bellatrix is taunting Molly about the death of Fred and Molly is saying that she - Bellatrix- will never touch her children again.

Carol:
 
I think, though, that any of Molly's sons would have been humiliated if she'd stepped in to take over their battle because it would insult their competence, their maturity, and their masculinity. With Ginny, a fellow female and a "child," her (perceived) interference won't be resented as much, especially since Ginny herself could never have killed Bellatrix. And once Ginny has children of her own, any lingering resentment of her mother's taking over her battle will disappear as her own mother instinct kicks in.
 
Carol, just speaking from her own experience with teenage boys and girls

Marianne:

You're so right Carol.  Evan as old as my kids are, especially with my daughter who is pregnant, if anyone messes with them my mother instinct kicks in and I will step in and protect them.  Daughter has meddlesome neighbor and I've stepped in between my daughter and the neighbor at times.  Not that neighbors would hurt her, but they aren't going to mess with her.

Marianne





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive