Harry Potter and God

kempermentor kempermentor at yahoo.com
Fri May 15 14:19:12 UTC 2009


> md:
> 
> Actually, I'm completely indifferent. I can't believe how people keep
> ... Of
> course, I think 3 & 5 are the best films and I was so happy to see Columbus out of the director's chair and a real film maker adding style and validity to the series -- as well as making the films about characters and not just plot 

Kemper now:
I cannot agree with you more.  The first two were like fresh zombies, looking like the original but without souls.  Columbus is overrated
I'll take the racist heads over the first two movies any night.


> md:
> My only thing is, as a writer, I don't want people second-guessing my choices in my world. 

Kemper now:
As a reader, I don't think the writer has that right.  You could always keep a private journal that no one has the right to read.  Being a fan does not mean nor require constructive criticism.  If you have fans bitching about what you wrote or condoned, you would still have fans.  No need to be an ungrate writer to them.

Kemper







More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive