Discussions about books and movies WAS: Re: Harry Potter and God

[dumbledore11214]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "Nightbreed" <md at ...> wrote:
> ------------------------------------
> I think you're missing my point which is the intensity and severity of the
> reaction some people have to different things not that they express their
> opinions.
> 
> md
>


Alla:

My point is still the same though - everything in the books and movies is a fair game for the critique on these lists as far as I am aware of. And it really really does not matter how passionate (or visceral) the reactions are, you know?

For example, I used to hate Severus Snape quite passionately before DH came out. I pretty much hate him with the same passion after DH came out.  And I would (hypothetically) really not react well if you or anybody else tell me that there is something WRONG with the intensity of my reactions, even if you were to graciously allow me the right to have them in the first place, you know? 


And it applies to any character or event, really.

 

JMO,

Alla