[HPFGU-OTChatter] Re: Harry Potter and God

[Lee Storm (God Is The Healing Force)]

[Carol]:
| My only question is who the other death (mentioned by Voldemort 
| in the opening chapter) had to be. Were they planning to 
| murder Mr. Crouch from the beginning? That doesn't make 
| sense. He was already Imperiused.

[Lee]:
I thought he was referring back to Bertha.  I'll have to read that chapter
again.

[Carol]:
| I don't agree that the kidnapping could have been done at any 
| time. It had to be when Wormtail's potion was ready (it 
| wasn't just blood, bone, and flesh). I don't know whether he 
| could just conjure a big stone cauldron, either. Maybe he 
| somehow had to obtain that. Meanwhile, the WW could feel 
| deludedly safe and Voldemort could plan what he intended to 
| do once he called the very surprised DEs to him in the 
| graveyard. I'm sure that Barty Jr. liked the plan, too, since 
| it enabled him to use his cleverness and feel important.

[Lee]:
I also don't believe Harry could have been kidnapped from the Hogwarts
Express without some commotion and, once he reached Hogwarts, he would be
very hard to kidnap unless it was done in a manner which looked like an
accident.  Barty Jr. fulfilled all that by tweaking things, so to speak.

[Carol]:
| At any rate, just calling Harry into his office and handing 
| him a portkey at whatever time he could manage wouldn't work 
| unless Voldemort and Wormtail were waiting in the graveyard 
| with the potion ready. It wouldn't do to have Harry 
| transported to the graveyard when they weren't there or just 
| transported to the Riddle's house to lie around and be 
| tortured while Wormtail did whatever he needed to do to get 
| that potion ready. Some potions, as you know, take months to 
| brew. Most likely this one, which, after all, restores 
| Voldemort to his own body, must have been extremely complicated.

[Lee]:
And if he did Portkey Harry at the wrong time, here's that commotion thing
again and a posse would no doubt go forth.

Cheers,

Lee :-)

Do not walk behind me,    | Lee Storm
I may not care to lead;   | N2FGC
Do not walk before me,    | n2fgc at arrl.net (or)
I may not care to follow; | n2fgc at optonline.net
Walk beside me, and be my friend.