Stoppering Death... no spoilers...

jenP_97 jenP_97 at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 2 20:00:00 UTC 2000


Original Yahoo! HPFG Header:
No: HPFGUIDX C5602
From: jenP_97
Subject: Re: Stoppering Death... no spoilers...
Reply To: [Yahoo! #5523] Re: Dumbeldores reaction
Date: 8/2/00 4:00 pm  (ET)

Taking the last part of Brooks' message, making it the first part of
a reply:

>>Re-read Snape's opening speech in first day of potions class in
Book I. He says "potions can even stopper death". I take that to mean
'put a stopper (that is, block up the hole) in the bottle from whence
death comes' - and I think he means this as a metaphor, not as a literal
intepretation of using a potion as a poison antidote. So if potions can
already stop death, what is Voldy trying to beat? <<

I didn't take Snape's words in that way. When he says "even stopper
death", I took that to mean that he can put death (i.e., a poison that
would cause death) in a vial and "stopper" it. Meaning that he can
make poisons... which is no big surprise, as when I consider magical
potions, the ones I most think of are ones that cause either great bodily
discomfort or death. :) Anyway, although that theory is interesting,
I don't think I can agree with you on it.

Jen (who wishes that several (unnamed) magic potions would pop up in
her medicine cabinet and correct all the minor problems in her life)






More information about the HPforGrownups-Archives archive