Wands

[Hot_Gazpacho]

Original Yahoo! HPFG Header:
No: HPFGUIDX C6281
From: Hot_Gazpacho
Subject: Re: Wands
Reply To: [Yahoo! #6234] Re: Wands
Date: 8/8/00 5:30 pm  (ET)

>Why don't you think that his wand ever was >broken? Hagrid tells them
that it was in SoS.

Yes, but he can barely look Ollivander in the face when he says his wand
was snapped in half, and then Ollivander gives him a long, piercing look,
like he doesn't quite believe him.

Now, Hagrid may have been looking down in shame at having his wand snapped
in half, but then why would he reply cheerfully (almost immediately
afterward), that he still has the pieces? I think his reply smacks
of someone who's pleased with themselves that they've come up with a
convinving lie.

Regards,
Hot Gazpacho