Mysteries and Inconsistencies Pt 2

david_the_bravest david_the_bravest at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 19 01:25:00 UTC 2000


Original Yahoo! HPFG Header:
No: HPFGUIDX C2220
From: david_the_bravest
Subject: Re: Mysteries and Inconsistencies Pt 2
Reply To: [Yahoo! #2216] Mysteries and Inconsistencies Pt 2
Date: 6/18/00 9:25 pm  (ET)

>How did Hagrid get the key to the Potter's Gringotts vault? Did he take
it from the ruins of the Potter's house? If so, why didn't Voldemort
take it?< voldemort was problay in a rush to get away so no one would
see him or sumthing mabey he was thinking he would return to power (ya
right...) and then just bust into gringotts and steal everyones money,
or mabey the potters gave it to a friend knowing the problay won't make
it and some one should get all the money. > How do new Hogwarts students
who come from muggle families know how to find Diagon Alley and Platform
9 3/4? [Maybe Hagrid, or a Hogwarts professor, visits each muggle family
to explain everything (since after all the letter must come as something
of a shock) and then takes the new student to Diagon Alley to buy their
school supplies] < the might get a note saying how to get in or where
to meet a wizard that could show you how.... > Why does Harry have to
continue to live with the Dursleys? After all, in Book 2 the Dursleys
tell him to find out if he can spend the summer at Hogwarts. Couldn't he
just hang out with Hagrid all summer? [I think the answer is simply that
Harry's adventures with the Dursleys are an important plot device that
JKR wants to continue.] < who says he would have to live with hagrid oln
the summer i think he would spend apart of the summer with ron and the
other part with hermione. > How come Moaning Myrtle is able to flood the
bathroom? Ghosts are supposed to be able to pass through matter without
disturbing it, and there are numerous references in the book to them
doing so, such as Professor Binns entering the classroom through the
blackboard. The water shouldn't move when Moaning Myrtle is inside the
toilet.< myrtle flods them by crying not splashing water around... >
Also, how come none of the above people except Lupin ever notice while
looking at the map that Ron is always accompanied by Peter Pettigrew?<
problay casue harry only used the map when ron was at hogsmead so he
couldn't see ron and he problay wasn't looking to she who was hanging in
there common room fred and geogre didn't need it so they problay hadn't
used it since book 1 and then they wouldn't be checking to see who was
sleeping in the common room... lupin problay didn't use it except for
that one time becasue he would know that if he saw sirus sneaking in
he would have a hard time explain how he came across the map and all
that... >Why do the dementors try to give Harry the kiss of death? <
becasue he interfeared with them trying to do it to sirus...






More information about the HPforGrownups-Archives archive