Hagrid's family

pt4ever pt4ever at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 19 06:00:00 UTC 2000


Original Yahoo! HPFG Header:
No: HPFGUIDX C2244
From: pt4ever
Subject: Re:  Hagrid's family
Reply To: [Yahoo! #2242] Re: MESSAGE FROM FOUNDER
Date: 6/19/00 2:00 am  (ET)

I had a thought about Hagrid today...

Wouldn't it be an interesting plot turn in book 4 if Hagrid was
re-admitted to Hogwarts? He was expelled in his third year for opening the
Chamber of Secrets. However, in book 2, it's proven beyond the shadow of
a doubt that Hagrid did NOT open the CoS and therefore did not deserve
to be expelled. He was made a teacher in PoA, but shouldn't he be able
to become a fully qualified wizard, as he would have if not for Tom
Riddle? (Of course, there's a chance he would have been expelled later
in his Hogwarts career for taking care of other "interesting creatures.")

If Hagrid was re-admitted to Hogwarts, he'd be in Harry's class
(a fourth-year)! Wouldn't that make for some interesting chapters? Of
course, maybe it's not possible for him to be re-admitted, if it's a
hard and fast rule that only children can be Hogwarts students....but
it would be interesting!

-- JoAnna






More information about the HPforGrownups-Archives archive