Book 5 title

Steve Vander Ark vderark at bccs.org
Wed Dec 13 17:55:28 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 6799


> sister.  And just on a side note, somewhere on your website i read 
the time 
> theory, which was intriguing, but when Mrs. Weasley talks about 
being caught 
> by the caretaker, i believe that she meant the man who preceeded 
Filch, not 
> Hagrid.  

I wonder if this doesn't refer to the time theory on the Lexicon? 
That's a different web site. It's not much of a theory and I should 
probably update it. I've updated the mysteries page, by the way, 
listing the Big Questions you guys all suggested to me. 

I just discovered another little inconsistency...in SS/PS Harry gets 
lost while roaming the halls at night and comes across a suit of 
armor. He knows there's a suit of armor like that by the kitchens, 
but he's at least five floors above that. But he obviously knows 
where the kitchens are. Of course, by the time he gets to GF, he's 
forgotten. Fred and George have to clue Hermione in, who then shows 
Harry and Ron. I suppose the kitchens could have moved around since 
1991, but conisdering their relationship with the Great Hall above, 
it doesnt' seem likely.

One more tiny but intriguing mystery to ponder and try to explain. 
Oh, I know, I know (hand waving Hermione style)-- That memory charm 
that Lockhart tried on them hit him just a tiny bit and he forgot 
just a few tidbits of information, that's all. Like where the 
kitchens were. Yeah, that explains it.

Steve ;)
The Harry Potter Lexicon
http://www.i2k.com/~svderark/lexiocn





More information about the HPforGrownups archive