[HPforGrownups] Digest Number 367 (Dee Note: OT)
Denise Rohleder
gypsycaine at yahoo.com
Wed Dec 27 01:23:48 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 7849
Maya,
I am not certain what you have embedded in your message (see about for info
about the original subject), but it asked me to download a "Unicode Hebrew
translator" to view your message, something I am not familiar with.
Does anyone else on the list know what this is, or why I gave me that
message?
Thanks!
************************************************************
~~Dee~~
:)
"Night is the hardest time to be alive.
It lasts so long, and 4am knows all my secrets."
(Poppy Brite)
Get ICQ and get connected! ICQ me @ 21282374
************************************************************
----- Original Message -----
From: "Maya Crabtree" <mayacrab at netvision.net.il>
To: <HPforGrownups at egroups.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 26, 2000 5:46 PM
Subject: Re: [HPforGrownups] Digest Number 367
>
> >In the delightful issue of who dies I have nothing to offer but my gut
> feelings.
> >First of all, I disagree with anyone who thinks that one of the major
> characters (Harry,
> >Hermione, Ron) will die. I will bet anybody my last knut that the end of
> book 7 will find
> >them alive and well (after M. Pomfrey regrows several of their organs,
> obviously).
>
>
> I tend to agree with that. Maybe I'm being naive, but let's not forget
that
> she writed for children, Okay, maybe more adults read it than children,
but
> as she often says, and as I heard her say in the interview with her I
> watched yersterday, seh exxentially still aims this for children reading,
> and so when she DOES kill, it won't be dramaticlly. So, no matter how many
> death eaters die - she will not go popping off "Good " carachters one by
> one. Whether you prefer Ron or Harry to "win" Hermione, or if they even go
> their own seperate ways (because, that's still AN option in the end,isn't
> it) there's no chance she's gonna kill the essential "Good".
>
>
> >I also quite firmly believe that these will not die either - Dumbledore
(if
> he dies, it
> >will be at the end of book 7 only),
>
> Actually, that guess makes my previous assersion a little unsound if I
agree
> with it. All along book 4 I though I saw signs of Dubledore's death (not
in
> book 4 ).It's pretry obvious, Harry mentiones how old Dunmbeldore's
looking
> infinite number of times...;-) So I do have a feeling he will either die
> naturally, or die heroiclly, but in a stage in which he knows he's not far
> from death any way., Not because he's not brave, but because he is too
> "Good" to die. I'd even started to imagine what the school would look like
> with a new principal (someone new, not Mcgonagall for some reason I don't
> know), and that Harry would have no one to turn to. But I am really at a
> loss about Dumbledore. On one hand, getting rid of him WILL make a change,
> because as it is now, all the books end like a murder mystery, the
detective
> uncoveres everything and solves the mystery - that's Dumbldore, On the
other
> hand - you just wouldn't feel safe. not just harry - but the reader as
> well, who always knows that whatever happens, Dumbledore will make all
right
> at the end...
>
> >These are the possible deaths (I feel like some kind of Trelawney now):
> Bill or Charley
> >Weasley, Crookshanks, either Lupin OR Sirius, a not very central teacher
> (Sprout, Flitwick .
>
> No. Sirius can't die. specially not if harry dies. My bet is on Lupin, who
> by all accounts is a VERY noble and good person, brave, intelligent , etc.
> We REALLY like him, right? Almost like serious or just as much as Sirius.
> However, he is not serious, so he is a much better candidate to kill. I
> suppose. However, I think I personally like him just as much as sirius. So
I
> really wouldn't want him killed.
>
> > Cho (I don't really think she'll die, though),
>
> Oh, I hope she does.
> :-)
> Sorry. not that I'm a H/H advocate. If I had to choose it'd be Ron, but I
> don';t know who's more likely, if any of them. The point is, this Harry
Cho
> thing is silly, I never liked it. oh, but if she dies, harry'll have to
> express emition and be sad. hm.. I thnk I still prefer that she DID die...
> :-)
>
> >Sorry about this, but I realized that in my haste I forgot my prime
> candidate for heroic
> >death - Dobby. Winkey, of course, is a gonner too.
> >
>
> Why davka Dobby?
>
>
> Maya
>
>
>
>
>
> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
> HPforGrownups-unsubscribe at egroups.com
>
>
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive