Ages? and Dumbledore's Mirror

[Penny & Bryce Linsenmayer]

No: HPFGUIDX 7899

Hi --

milz wrote:

> The trouble spots for figuring out the Weasley ages is the date of
> the last time Gryffindor won the House Quidditch Cup (CoS) and in GoF
> where Bill states the last time he was at Hogwarts was 5 years ago.

I still say that the 5 yr statement cannot be taken to mean that Bill
was last at Hogwarts as a student 5 years ago (making him 23 in GoF).
He's visiting Hogwarts then (in GoF) as an alumni, so if 5 years later,
he comes back & makes the statement that it's been 5 yrs since he last
saw Hogwarts, it wouldn't be right to conclude that he'd only been out
of school 5 years in that case.  See the logic or am I rambling?  He
could have visited Hogwarts as an alumni 5 yrs prior to GoF.

Penny



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]