[HPforGrownups] Re: Ages? and Dumbledore's Mirror

[Stephanie Becvar]

No: HPFGUIDX 7926

>I still say that the 5 yr statement cannot be taken to mean that Bill
>was last at Hogwarts as a student 5 years ago (making him 23 in GoF).
>He's visiting Hogwarts then (in GoF) as an alumni, so if 5 years later,
>he comes back & makes the statement that it's been 5 yrs since he last
>saw Hogwarts, it wouldn't be right to conclude that he'd only been out
>of school 5 years in that case.  See the logic or am I rambling?  He
>could have visited Hogwarts as an alumni 5 yrs prior to GoF.
>
>Pennybut why 5 years ago?  I mean, the twins would have been in their 1st 
>year, so he wouldnt have been coming to watch them play Quidditch, and 
>Percy would have been in his 3rd year, but he didnt play Quidditch.  This 
>always confised me a lot....bc I want to know what he was doing there...

_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com