[HPforGrownups] Death Eater Roll Call?

[Dinah]

No: HPFGUIDX 7955

> 2)"who I believe has left me forever" (probably Snape)

First I thought so, too (it just has to be him, right?) but then I stumbled
about Snape spying again - which he couldn't do if they knew he had betrayed
them. Sorry for being redundant, this has been said several times now, but
how else could he have done it?

On the other hand this would mean that he actually was in the cave and
didn't interfere! Or did he? I really think he is on Dumbledore's side, and
how Hary got out of that cave is all in a blur, he doesn't even realize how
he finally manages it, shooting spells over his back and so on - so Snape
might have helped him. Kinda late, but still...

Actually, I don't think he was there, but it is just a thought that occured
to me.

Quite confusing.

Dinah