Rickman as Snape

[Susan McGee]

No: HPFGUIDX 2742

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, eliasberg at i... wrote:
> Susan, 
> 
> I think you should watch Die Hard, Rickman is perfect as Snape. 
> As for the abused child syndrome, you should try to remember 
> that it is a book, a fantasy book, that was trying to make a point 
> that no matter how bad it gets there is hope at the end of the 
> tunnel. You should watch JKRs interviews and she talks about 
> Harry's treatment and why he is treated as poorly as he is. 
> Perhaps you should shelve the credentials and listen to what 
> Dumbledore says, " it is the decisions we make that make us 
> who we are".

Actually, Dumbledore says "choices" not decision. I may reconsider
about Rickman.

Should, should, should...I don't do well with shoulds..

I have listened to JKRs interviews. 

My credentials reflect my real life experience with kids. Abused kids 
are a subject that I feel passionately about. No child should ever be
treated the way Harry was treated. You have the right to feel 
passionately about whatever, but 

Perhaps you should shelve the shoulds.


Susan