Playstation and relationships
Susan McGee
Schlobin at aol.com
Sun Oct 8 03:16:19 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 2943
--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, "Simon J. Branford"
<simon.branford at h...> wrote:
> Steve wrote: "There's a page on the Harry Potter Lexicon which
talks about
> some of the day vs. date questions as well as the problems with
years
> (PlayStations were invented when?) in the series."
>
> Is the bit about playstation's a question or comment? If it is a
question to
> the group then it is worth reading message 714 and is replies.
>
> I wrote: "Also the wrong person tag could be an indication that he
was
> chasing after her and never got her. I could also argue that JKR
said that
> they would end up with the wrong people in book 4. Harry ended up
with
> Pavarti in book 4 and not Cho. So this could also indicate that
Harry/Cho is
> still a possibility."
>
> Penny replied: "Okay. As long as I'm free to use the same basic
logic and
> say that Hermione is the "wrong" person for Ron since Ron fell for
her in
> Book 4 (even though he didn't know or acknowledge it). <g>"
>
> Continuing with my logic, IMHO, would mean that Padma or Fleur was
the wrong
> person for Ron. This is something we are always going to have
arguments and
> disagree on. Even if JKR settles the debate then some of us will
still say
> the pairings are wrong! That is part of the reason I go for some of
the more
> wacky options. <vbg>
>
> Neil wrote: "One or other or both of these could be true. I'm
swinging more
> towards > Harry-Hermione-post-Hogwarts these days [thanks Lori],"
>
> Penny replied: "Wow! :--)"
>
> Lori has swayed many, but some of these still think it would
require Ron
> dying. I for one only support the partnership only if Ron is not a
factor in
> their lives anymore.
>
> Neil wrote: "but I still favour the idea that they'll all three
remain just
> best friends and end up with other partners."
>
> Penny replied: "At Hogwarts? If so -- that might be preferable
(not likely
> given Ron's interest in Hermione but preferable perhaps). Post-
Hogwarts --
> well, everyone knows my preference."
>
> But it is still possible that, even after Ron has admitted his
feeling for
> Hermione (and maybe the reverse, or Hermione for Harry, etc...),
that the
> three just remain friends.
>
> Simon
Or what about a menage a trois? Then we could all have our cake
and eat it too
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive