Literal interpretations?
Jim Flanagan
jamesf at alumni.caltech.edu
Sun Oct 8 18:01:32 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 2962
Just to throw another monkey wrench into the dating business: has
anyone considered the effect of the Julian/Gregorian calendar change
on some of the back-dating that has been done? Over here in the
colonies, the calendar changed in the year 1752. In that year 11
days were dropped from September, and New Years Day changed from
March 25 to January 1. This makes it difficult to figure out what
the 500th "Anniversary" of Nick's execution actually refers to -- is
it exactly 365.25 X 500 days, or just the same calendar date, which
could be off by at least 11 days from exactly 500 years? (Eastern
Orthodox churches still follow the old calendar.)
Another thing that has been bugging me is the too-literal
interpretation of offhand statements in the books. For example,
Hagrid says that *all* the wizards who have turned out bad have come
from Slitherin (sorry, I couldn't find the exact quote). Is that to
be taken literally? If Hagrid were from Texas (like myself) I'd have
to take this statement with a grain of salt, since we Texans are
inclined to exaggerate *just a tad* for effect. Different
nationalities have reputations for exaggeration: the Irish are widely
known for "blarney," but the Scots and Germans are considered more
strait-laced. Do the people from rural south-west England (presumably
where Hagrid is from) have a reputation for hyperbole? If so, then
we should not look only to Slitherin for potential Death Eaters.
-Jim Flanagan
"When you're in Odessa, Texas, check out The World's Largest
Jackrabbit."
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive