J.K. Rowling Appearances

[Steve Bates]

No: HPFGUIDX 3665

> My plan is to also submit one question from the group to the B&N
> interview & to the Scholastic interview (I have no idea how to get 
into
> the AOL interview while it's going on).  I'm trying to go for 
questions
> that would be relatively easy for her to answer (brief questions 
that
> elicit rather brief replies).  I decided that the number of students
> issue falls into that category for the most part.
> 
> Does anyone want to give me some thoughts on 2 other questions for 
these
> other interviews?  Some of our oft-debated questions tend to involve
> rather detailed or lengthy explanations to get the point across 
(and can
> likewise be expected to require more detailed answers frome her) -
> therefore are unlikely to be selected by the moderator or 
answered.  I
> had thought about the ancestor-descendant debate -- the question 
itself
> could probably be phrased relatively simply if I try hard.  Any
> thoughts?
>

Can we ask about whether Lupin needs to actually be under the light 
of the full moon to transform? Is there a simple way to summarize why 
we think PoA is self-contradictory about this topic?  It would 
take a better writer than me to phrase the question well.