[HPforGrownups] Re: Neville and Snape

[Amanda Lewanski]

No: HPFGUIDX 3891

mmarth at peoplepc.com wrote:

> First off, just because Snape has the mark doesn't mean he was one.
> He could have only been "acting" at the time.

Aha! Semantics. I meant he was one in the sense that he was fully enrolled
and considered one by Voldemort and any other DeathEaters who knew, whatever
his own heart said at the time.

> Martha
>
> Whose only contribution to society and women today will be to get the
> dirty dishes cleaned.  Oh, and the laundry also!

No, that's a contribution to self-preservation and good taste.

> I still don't like the Snape/Lily theory and will only believe it
> after the 7th book.  By then I will know 98% of my theories will have
> been wrong.

Won't we all....but ain't it fun?

--Amanda