[HPforGrownups] Mysteries of McGonagall

[Amanda Lewanski]

No: HPFGUIDX 4163

Neil Ward wrote:

> I have always found it strange that she asked him how he knew it was her?
> (After changing from cat to
> >Professor).  Has Dumbledore never seen her in her cat form?  After all
> those years?
>
> Yes, I agree.  I posted something on that very point ages ago. Is Dumbledore
> *that* lacking in observation? Perhaps he left that knowledge in his
> Pensieve and forgot to put it back in his head.

Even odder, considering he was the Transfiguration teacher prior to his
headmastership.

--Amanda