Hagrid's (school) House, (not his hut)
Scott
harry_potter00 at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 21 03:11:50 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 4235
>>Kelly wrote-
>>Someone posted that JKR said that Hagrid was in Gryff.;
> didn't it say Hagrid was in Huff in one of the books? Harry
> says "I'll probably be in Huff," and doesn't Hagrid say "~I~ was
in
> Huff..." or something like that? I could swear I saw this
somewhere,
> maybe not that exchange, but that it's stated that Hagrid was in
> Huff. Am I nuts? All right, all right, we know the answer to that
> one, keep your comments to yourselves... ;o]
Well don't feel bad, I already know that I'm completly daffy and I
agree with you here! I KNOW (well of course I could be wrong) that
it said Hagrid was in Hufflepuff, or else STRONGLY implied (I'm
thinking the former as we both deduced this...)
The pasage to which you refered is this...
*******
"And what are Slytherin and Hufflepuff?"
"School houses. There's four. Everyone says Hufflepuff are a bunch o'
duffers but-"
I bet I'm in Hufflepuff," said Harry.
"Better in Hufflepuff than in Slytherin," said Hagrid darkly...
*****
Hagrid's "but-" could easily of been "I was in Hufflepuff." or "Your
Dad was in Hufflepuff" (though I feel JKR has indirectly disproved
the latter.)
Another interesting thing is that the British Subject verb agreement
(Hufflepuff are) is used and not (Hufflepuff is) which is the
American way. ( and if this is wrong just remember I'm not the best
at grammar)
Errr, anyway can anybody clear up this rather shadowy assumption that
Hagrid was in Hufflepuff (besides the JKR chat)... I just can't stop
think ing that it was SOMEWHERE in CoS. I shall continue to peruse
but if anyone knows anything....
Scott
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive