Dumbledore an animagus?
milz
absinthe at mad.scientist.com
Sat Oct 21 13:54:22 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 4278
--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, Neil Ward <neilward at d...> wrote:
> Milz wrote:
>
> >This is just a thought, but considering Dumblebore was the
> >Transfiguration Teacher, could he also be an un-registered
animagus?
> >There's a part in SS that's always puzzled me...Harry tells
> >Dumbledore that they sent an owl to him in London. Dumbledore
replies that he
> >didn't get the owl and that they must have passed each other in
the
> >air (or something like that). I thought at first Dumbledore was
> >traveling via broomstick, but wouldn't he have noticed the owl?
Also,
> >'dumbledore' is an archaic word meaning "bumblebee".
>
> Good point. There's also the bit in PS, when Harry is visiting the
Mirror
> of Erised and Dumbledore appears from nowhere. Harry had
apparently
walked
> past Dumbledore to get into the room, and Dumbledore makes a
comment
about
> being invisible making Harry "near-sighted". Later, he tells Harry
"I don't
> need a cloak to become invisible...". A bumblebee sitting on the
table
> would be virtually invisible.
>
> I'm not so sure that Dumbledore would be an unregistered Animagus,
and that
> raises an inconsistency: why didn't Hermione see his name listed as
one of
> the registered Animagi? It's a nice idea though.
>
> Neil
>
If he is an unregistered animagus, perhaps that's the reason why he
appeared to take the Sirius/Padfoot thing rather calmly. Lupin had
misgivings about telling Dumbledore that Sirius was an unregistered
animagus because he felt guilty. Yet, Dumbledore didn't fire him and
appeared as thought he wanted Lupin to stay.
:-) Milz
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive