Scabbers

[Susan McGee]

No: HPFGUIDX 4505

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, "Joywitch " <joym999 at a...> wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, Angela Boyko <aboyko at n...> wrote:
> > Penny & Bryce Linsenmayer wrote:
> > 
> > > Caius Marcius wrote:

Now surely, as one of the authors of the Marauders' Map, Peter would 
have  known what precautions to take to prevent his name from showing 
 up on the Map.

But, Lupin found him on it.  Are you suggesting that he 
> (Scabbers) just
"slipped up" when Lupin spied him on the Map in PoA?  Lupin also 
> says
that the "Map never lies."  I don't know that Pettigrew could have
prevented himself from showing up on it.

Perhaps the authors of the map were only visible to each other ... 
> the
> > map wouldn't have lied, but concealed Peter's presence to 
everyone 
> but a
> > fellow author?
> > 
> > Angela "Hi, I'm new" Boyko
> 


> Wow!  Ingenous theory, I like it!  It fits in with the personality 
of 
> the Marauders as teenagers, fits in with the plot, and clears up 
what 
> seems to be a plot hole.  Welcome to the group Angela, and keep the 
> brilliant deductions coming!
> 
> -- Joywitch


Doesn't Harry in PoA and Hermione look at the Map and see both
Lupin and Black on it?

S