Harry's grandparents

[foxmoth at qnet.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 4621

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, Amanda Lewanski <editor at t...> wrote:

> It can be argued, I suppose, that this statement is based on
Harry's knowledge
> and is thus subject to further revelation, but coupled with what
Dumbledore's
> already said, I'm inclined to accept this at face value. They're
it. Doncha
> think?

Yer right, I forgot about that line in POA. Rats!
> 
> 
> 
> Um, why's James out of the house every full moon? Presumably after
he got
> married he stopped the moonlit revels with Lupin and the others.
And Snape
> (who I presume is your proposed imposter) is unpleasant, conniving,
nasty, and
> mean, but not unscrupulous.

What, you think James would leave his old friend Remus to suffer as a 
mindless ravening monster? Why?
	As for Snape's scruples, he would, in this scenario, have been an 
active Death Eater at the time...and not yet returned to Our Side. 
> 
> >         BTW, the idea does *not* come from Star Wars...it's from 
Le Morte
> > Darthur...George stole it from Tom (Malory, not Riddle).
> 
> Um, slow day here, but where was this in Star Wars? 
	The hero  discovers in horror that he has family ties to his 
enemies. 
> > Pippin (ducking pillows now)

> most of the projectiles handy to my
> terminal are small and hard or pointy, and I'm far too lazy to get
up just to
> get you a soft one....
> 
> --Amanda
Virtual ouch!
Pippin<g>