Harry's Summer Holidays Post Voldy
Jim Ferer
jferer at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 3 17:15:58 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 866
Peg,
I don't see the Durselys treating Harry any better this summer than
last, when they at least left him alone for fear of Sirius Black.
I get bothered sometimes by how, in the wizarding world, some bad
things are allowed to happen. A lot of schools wouldn't tolerate
Snape's behavior towards some students, nor would they tolerate
teaching as poor as Gilderoy Lockhart's was. Back on the point,
though, I'd have to guess Dumbledore wouldn't have contacted the
Dursleys and attempted to change their behavior.
Peg Kerr wrote,
> What also has really struck me is how different Draco's summer
holiday might be. I think Draco might really be at a similar
turning point. Cornelius Fudge might not believe it, but Lucius
Malfoy has really gone back to Voldemort, now. Draco might have
sneered at H, R and Hr about Cedric's death, but when he goes back
home, he's going to be facing parents (or at least a father) who are
working actively to promote the dark powers. Will what he sees this
summer shake him up a little? Will he start having second thoughts
about his loyalties? Will Daddy maybe have a little less time to pay
attention to Dudley [you meant Draco, I'm sure] because he's started
murdering people? How will that make Draco feel? And what will Draco
be like when HE comes back to Hogworts? Even more swaggering and
sneering?Or . . . maybe, a bit thoughtful and quieter, and not so
quick to sneer?
>
Good thoughts. It ties in with my notions of of one of the things
JKR is trying to do in these books. Among other things, she wants
her
young readers to realize that bad is *bad*.
I don't know how many messages I've seen on boards frequented by
younger readers that say "wouldn't it be cool if Harry went to the
Dark Side?" "I think the Dark stuff is cool!" That kind of thing.
These kids have grown up on cartoon-funny Scooby-Doo villains and
moved on to the cooler than the good guy Disney villains and the
World
Wrestling Federation [their HQ is about 600 feet from where I'm
sitting]. Heck, a lot of us grew up watching the bumbling funny Nazi
guards on Hogan's Heroes, a program I found offensive.
Your point is that Draco is going to have to come to grips with what
it means to be Dark, the same journey I hope some of the readers
take.
It's the same journey Snape made and still struggles with. Will it
come out the same way?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive