[HPforGrownups] Re: Animals on Marauder's Map (Was: Mrs Norris: A Character Study)

[Warmsley]

No: HPFGUIDX 1081

>I just saw the weakness in my argument and a way to explain it
away.
>Lupin saw Peter Pettigrew's name on the Map even while he was
in rat
>form.  But I guess it's still possible that the map shows the
name
>that the person using the map has for each person.  So, since
Lupin
>knew Wormtail as Peter Pettigrew, the map showed him "Peter
>Pettigrew" but since the twins knew Wormtail as Scabbers, the
map
>showed them "Scabbers".
>


Nope, that doesn't work either, sadly - Harry saw Moody as Barty
Crouch, remember?

Jeremy