Also from September 6, 2000 USA Today
heidi tandy
heidi.h.tandy.c92 at alumni.upenn.edu
Thu Sep 7 19:27:35 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 1137
This is the "Against Book Banning" editorial - (also, are all of you
members of Muggles for Harry Potter yet?)
Harry Potter faces biggest foe yet in book censors
School's open, and Harry Potter is under attack -- again.
This time the enemy is not the fictitious forces of evil whom the
young apprentice-wizard fights off in the wildly popular books by
J.K. Rowling. It's the very real forces of self-appointed censors who
want to tell other people's children what they can read.
In just the opening days of the school year, the American Library
Association already has received reports from Texas, South Carolina
and Illinois of new efforts to purge Harry and his friends from
schools.
It may sound strange to the millions of children and adults who
embrace the Potter stories for their imaginative charm, but some
object to Harry and his friends at Hogwarts School on grounds they
may draw youngsters into the occult. In addition to being No. 1 on
best-seller lists for months, the Potter books also were the No. 1
target last year of efforts to pressure libraries and schools into
making the books difficult or impossible to get. But Harry is in good
company.
Of the Modern Library's 100 best novels of the 20th century, one-
third have been removed or threatened with removal from bookstores,
libraries and schools at some point. Among the 10 most-challenged
books of 1999, Harry Potter edged out such perennial targets as the
works of Judy Blume, Margaret Atwood, Maya Angelou and John Steinbeck.
And the assaults on freedom to read don't come just from those whose
mission is to spare the world from thinking about sex or coarse
language. Mark Twain's Adventures of Huckleberry Finn remains one of
the most-challenged books of the decade because of attacks from the
politically correct espousing an ostrichlike attitude toward the
abuse experienced by blacks in the 19th century.
The Library Association counted 500 formal protests and demands for
withdrawal of books erupting in more than half the states last year.
The good news is that in most communities there is resistance.
In Zeeland, Mich., the schools panicked in front of criticism, barred
all classroom reading of Harry Potter books last year and removed
them from open shelves of the libraries. But parents, students and
teachers, seizing the word for the non-magical ordinary people in
Rowling's books, organized ''Muggles for Harry Potter.''
They circulated a petition, spoke up at school board meetings and
held protests. The superintendent backed down, removing most of his
restrictions. Muggles is now a nationwide movement, with more than
13,000 members as of last week. And the youngsters involved are
getting a valuable civic lesson: that access to books is not
automatic and must be fought for.
As plucky Harry surely knows, a triumph for freedom today doesn't
mean there won't have to be another battle tomorrow.Today's debate:
Back-to-school censorship Groups across country renew efforts to ban
books from schools.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive