Priori Incantatem and ghost food

Ken Waghorne waghorne at ma.ultranet.com
Fri Sep 15 01:37:22 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 1452

cassandraclaire73 at yahoo.com wrote:  
>   
> That seems right; even if James somehow managed to linger on  
in a not-  
> quite-dead state after Voldemort performed the Avada Kedavra  
curse on   
> him, the wand still regurgitates spells in-the-order-performed,   
> ergo...Lily first, then James. I'm only saying this because I've  
> heard   
> the not-quite-dead-James arguement before and thought "that  
doesn't   
> work."  

Maybe James was protecting Harry while in the not-quite-dead  
stage somehow.  Then he could have been finished off in the curse  
that was directed at Harry, explaining why he emerged from V's  
wand out of the anticipated order.  The energy it took to send  
James to the quite-dead stage somehow altered V's spell and 
when combined with Lilly's protection led to the rebound onto V.  It  
also wiped out the house at the same time.    

OK, those are reaches, but will work for me until HP5 arrives.   


Ken



------------------------------------------------------------
Ken Waghorne
waghorne at ma.ultranet.com




More information about the HPforGrownups archive