Slytherin's evil

[Sam Brown]

No: HPFGUIDX 1875

> but then wouldn't this mean that Pettigrew must have 
> been in Slyth?  

Not necessarily, as we are only getting this information from Hagrid, 
who is not aware that Pettigrew was a spy. However the hole in that 
theory is that Hagrid thought Sirius Black was a dark wizard, which 
implies that Sirius was a Slytherin. Hmmm...

> Maybe Pettigrew and the rest of the Marauders were in 
> Slyth when they were at HW.

Despite what I just said it seems extremely unlikely that Sirius, 
James, Lupin, etc, were all in Slytherin. Wouldn't that make them 
friends with Snape and not enemies? I always got the impression that 
James was in Gryff (because of the whole familes/house thing, eg the 
Weasleys, altho in GoF there IS evidence to the contrary), and that 
therefore the rest of the Marauders were Gryffs too, simply because 
we haven't really hear much about interhouse friendships in Hogwarts.