Should HP msrry GW and die?
Rita Winston
catlady at wicca.net
Sun Sep 24 16:04:26 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 2049
--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, eggplant88 at h... wrote:
> Just one month after his marriage to Ginny Harry finds Voldemort
> and has a duel one on one with him. (snip)
> She looks down into the brilliant green eyes of her infant son
> cradled in her arms and kisses Harry Potter on the forehead. She
> sees no scar.
Combining this post with your other post that describes H falling in
love with G at the beginning of Book 5, you have written a clear and
entertaining explanation of your plot, and ended it with the word
that we have been told will end the series. I don't think it is an
accurate prediction of what JKR is going to do, partly because I just
don't believe that she would be so cynical as to create a Harry
Potter Junior just in case she wants to cash in on some more books.
Sure, it can be argued that for the hero to die gloriously but leave
behind a child to comfort the reader that life goes on is both an
archetypal story and an example of real life (tm), in which human
beings die but the human species goes on. However, my intuition is
that JKR's epic is following some other archetype.
Why did you pick Ginny rather than Hermione (or Mary-Sue)? Is it that
you perceive Ginny as having a great big loving heart with no
ambition to be distracted by, and thus more able to swamp Harry in an
ocean of unconditional love, or that you're sure that Hermione
belongs with Ron (or Viktor)?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive