Viewing the Tri Wizard challenges (long)
foxmoth at qnet.com
foxmoth at qnet.com
Wed Sep 27 19:46:36 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 2355
Well, the problem seems to be, if people could see inside the maze, why
didn't they know Harry was missing, or that Krum had used an illegal
curse. And if they couldn't see inside the maze why in heck would they
be out there watching? Of course we could just say it's poor plotting,
but where's the fun in that? It could work like this.
Hagrid, McGonagall, Moody and Flitwick patrol outside the maze.
ch. 31 p. 620
Moody uses his magical eye (and probably the marauders map) to track
the champions and make sure Harry reaches the cup first. ch. 35 p. 627
There is a one hundred yard sightline to the Triwizard cup ch. 31, p.
631
(Presumably the judges and the people in the stands can see what is
happening to it.)
Ludo is doing commentary, which no one inside the maze can hear. ch.
31, p.621
Cedric sends up sparks to get help for Krum. ch. 31 p. 627
Now to speculate:
when the sparks fly,
Moody and the other patrollers enter the maze. They discover that
Fleur and Krum have been attacked, evidently by Harry and/or Cedric.
The attacks themselves were concealed by the hedges. The patrollers
notify the judges, decoying Dumbledore, Maxime and Karkaroff away from
the judges box, leaving Fudge and Bagman on their own.
Then Moody slips away on some pretext, puts on the invisibility
cloak and sneaks out of the maze, still monitoring Harry's progress
with the map. When Harry and Cedric vanish, Moody puts the confundus
curse on Fudge and Bagman to keep them from realizing that anything
is amiss. Ludo's commentary to the crowd accounts for Harry and
Cedric's absence. ("They'll be joining us here shortly.")
When the resurrected Voldemort summons the death eaters,
Karkaroff, Moody, and Snape all feel the dark mark burn. Snape rushes
to find Dumbledore and report. At that point Dumbledore realizes that
the dragon dung has seriously hit the windmill, but he does not yet
know that Harry is missing.
Dumbledore's first move is, as it has been in the past, to
evacuate the students. As he returns to the judges' box to arrange
this, Karkaroff makes his escape. Madame Maxime sees to Fleur and her
other students. Moody, watching on the map, takes the confundus curse
off Fudge and Bagman just before Dumbledor arrives. Moody then
reappears and calmly awaits developments, expecting no doubt the
imminent arrival of Lord V. and the DEs (could be a good band name).
Just as Fudge, Dumbledore and Bagman come to the horrified realization
that Harry and Cedric are missing, Harry and Cedric return. JKR takes
it from there.
Please feel free to pick holes in this!
Pippin, who has spent way too much time working this out.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive