More Wand stuff

jazzman4 at earthlink.net jazzman4 at earthlink.net
Thu Sep 28 05:17:42 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 2404

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, Amanda Lewanski <editor at t...> wrote:
> Brooks R wrote:
> 
> > My theory now is that it
> > discorporated with him and re-corporated when he was (as 
'Mini-V'),
> > versus the theory that the current wand is not his at all,which I
> > think is stretching too far and makes things all the way back in 
Book
> > I become red herrings.
> 
> Who has proposed the latter? That the current wand isn't his? 
> --Amanda

That would be me, Amanda.  I'm just not satisfied with any of the 
proposed theories as to how the wand got back into Voldemort's hands. 
 I could be wrong about this, of course, but I've also come up with 
another line of thinking to support Harry's power generating what 
looks like Priori Incantatem (but isn't), and this one does not
depend 
on Voldemort having a ringer wand.  See "Rowling's a Slippery Wench," 
 message 2403.

Yes, this is a double post, referencing the correct message this time.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive