Lupin and the Marauder's Map
brandgwen at hotmail.com
brandgwen at hotmail.com
Sun Apr 1 14:51:28 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 15732
Raven wrote:
> Lupin tells Harry in the Shreiking Shack that he saw him and
Hermione on the Marauder's Map going to visit Hagrid and then going
into the Whomping Willow. Why, then, didn't he see the OTHER Harry
and Hermione in the Forbidden Forest, too? We know from Harry's
Crouch Sr. experience in GOF that the map covers at least the
outskirts of the forest. Any theories?
No theories, sorry. Instead another question. Lupin said he saw
Harry, Ron and Hermione not just go to Hagrids, but enter the hut.
This suggests to me that the hut is on the map.
If this is the case, why don't people inside the hut show up on the
map? People inside the castle do. However, Lupin speaks of the three
coming and going, but not what they do in the mean time. Further,
Harry never noticed Pettigrew's dot on the map, between his
disappearance and recovery.
Could it be that the mapmakers didn't plot the interior of Hagrid's
hut and garden? Wouldn't it, then, make a wonderful hiding place for
miscellaneous miscreants to hide?
Pettigrew (PoA) and Sirius (GoF) both used it, so why not?
Cheers,
Gwen.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive