Wizard existence to Muggle government?
LynnP333 at aol.com
LynnP333 at aol.com
Sat Apr 14 16:08:20 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 16734
***Cristin observed:
***
Fudge has been criticized by come members of the International Federation of
Warlocks for
informing the Muggle Prime Minister of the crisis.
<snip>
Now, since Fudge simply reported the incident directly to the PM, we must
assume that the
Muggle government is, if nothing else, aware of the existence of the
wizarding world -
<snip>
We would, I suppose, have to then extrapolate that then most, if not all, of
the important
world governments and organizations would be aware of the wizarding world.
How then, do you suppose each countries respective Ministry keeps the gov'ts
and
organizations quiet? It can't just be the leader of each country. Past
leaders, going back
quite far, would have to have known. As well as advisors, etc. And these
individuals would
not have family in the Wizarding World, and so little incentive to keep them
quiet. wizards
would have to be going around doing memory charms constantly, IMO.
Any ideas on how the relations would work?
****
Interesting can of worms you opened Cristin!
I can imagine a combination of memory charms and working with special
government divisions to keep things quiet. I also don't think any individual
in the various governments would bother to speak up about the wizarding world
and be seen as of a some kind of nut case and possibly risk their career.
Muggle leaders and the other government officials dealing with the wizards
IMO, would always be aware of the power wizards actually hold over them.
This in itself makes me believe Muggles and wizards can only come to an
uneasy coexistence. As much as the majority of wizards may feel benign
toward Muggles, the Muggles would always know that the wizards hold an
unbelievable power over them if they chose to use it. I can actually see a
lot more hostility from the Muggle side toward wizards, than from the wizard
side toward Muggles, if the two worlds came together. Perhaps the leaders of
the muggle world and wizard world realized this and thought it best to keep
the two apart for both their sakes? I could see some tempation of some
Muggle leaders to exploit the wizards, and maybe they've even tried in the
past, but I don't think they'd have had much success. <g!>
It would be interesting to read a book called 'A History of Muggle and Wizard
Relations' in the Hogwarts library. :-)
Lynn
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive