S. Snape suspected snake speech?
MMMfanfic at hotmail.com
MMMfanfic at hotmail.com
Sun Apr 15 13:38:13 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 16814
The duelling club scene was right after Harry blew up Snape's
classroom. Harry said that Snape knew it was him and would find
some 'foul' way to get him. It's entirely possible and in character
for Snape to accidentally let the whole school knows that Harry is a
Parseltongue. (like Lupin's condition -- see the pattern emerging?)
Of course, it could well be a coincidence -- JKR has to put the
discovery in somewhere. But since it's JKR, I doubt it.
The question (if Snape knew beforehand): How did Snape know Harry is
a Parselmouth? Did Dumbledore told him or is it something else?
The question (if Snape didn't knew): Given the amount of time he
spent with the other parselmouth, wouldn't he be at least slightly
pale or surprised at the discovery of another one?
Also notice how expelliarum has fast-becoming the all-purpose, all
occassion spell for Harry? Attack by a giant spider or an evil dark
lord or a phantom from a diary or a half-wit DADA professor or an
unbalanced Potions Master? Expelliarum! Expelliarum!
My question is: Why did JKR get Snape to teach Harry the most useful
spell in the book? Is it significant that Harry is unusually good at
the disarming spell? Is a cigar just a cigar?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive