Its Harry Fortnight!
inyron at yahoo.com
inyron at yahoo.com
Wed Apr 18 21:48:26 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 17090
I know some of you have lives, which is why Harry Fortnight is a
little late in getting started. But apparently I don't, so I wanted
to post.
Literary analysis, and analyzing diffrent passages and people are
great. Unfortunately, I'm not good at that. When I originally got
the books and read through them a few dozen times (OK, only six or
seven each. or eight.) I wasn't that impressed with Harry as a
character. I spent a lot of time thinking about the twins, or Ron or
Hermione, or Lupin, but I just saw Harry as everyboy, not that
distinctive. He was just a vehicle to show us this wonderful world.
I suppose I managed to ignore him for so many re-reads because I was
just concentrating on the adventure aspect.
Then I got my computer back from storage. Fanfiction was the first
place I turned. But I wasn't that interested in stories with Harry
anyway, so I didn't read too many. It wasn't until I got here, to
this egroup a couple months ago (I lurk a lot) that I really started
looking at Harry differently, mostly because of what you guys point
out. I began to see the decisions he makes as part of his
personality, rather than just "I have to do this to get the plot to
point B."
Like his grown-up trust issues. Growing up with the Dursleys, he
learned that grown-ups were useless, and you should just keep your
mouth shut, which is why he didn't tell Dumbledore about the voices
in the walls, which is why (as someone said) his interactions with
Lupin were such a big deal, which is why (as someone said) it was so
hard for him to go to Dumbledore when his scar was hurting. I did
NOT get that the first time around. "Why is he hesitating to go to
Dumbledore? Shouldn't he be anxious? Why is Dumbledore thanking him
so gravely?"
Someone else pointed out, during Ron Week, that while Hermione was
fighting with the boys, Ron said some mean things, but Harry wasn't
much help either, he was being very passive-aggressive about it. I
reread (again) SS two nights ago, and was a bit taken aback at the
meanness of a lot of Harry's thoughts. It was the same thing. Ron
was saying it out loud, and Harry's being very quiet, but agreeing
completely. Again, I never really noticed this.
Oh, and I now realize how super-brave he is. Really.
In retrospect, I guess these things are obvious, which is why I said
I sucked at analysis.
Now I've begun to enjoy Harry fanfiction, and boy oh boy, I thought I
was looking forward to OotP *before*
So, thank you guys very much. And I hope, for the rest of Harry
Fortnight you will continue to enlighten me on what makes Harry tick,
I don't think I'm completely there. So, a couple of questions, if
you please-
*Harry really doesn't socialize much, outside the troika (is this the
term we're using now?) Not even so much with his Quidditch-mates.
The Weasley's were the first wizarding family he met, and they proved
very enlightening and friendly. But, If Harry had sat alone with,
say, Seamus, during the ride to Hogwarts, do you think he and Ron
would still be best friends?
*Why does he keep referring to Ron as "Weasley" in FB?
*I love Sirius as much as the next girl, but how did he become the
most important grown-up in Harry's life about an hour after breaking
Ron's leg? And acting, you know, all yellow-teethed and insane?
After learning who MWPP were, you'd think he'd have a greater
appreciation for Lupin too.
OK, I guess that's it for now. Sorry I couldn't identify all of
the "someones" whose ideas I absorbed.
inyron
who wants to give a shout out to members of granger-weasley, and HP-
Paradise, and point out, hey, I'm not afraid of posting here!
Really.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive