[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape as teacher/Ambition

[Dinah]

No: HPFGUIDX 17118

> (apart for the comment to > Hermione.)>
> Catherine

Yes, the "I see no difference" comment. I talked with my mother about it a
few minutes ago. She hasn't read GoF yet and I explained the situation to
her and was really surprised. She doesn't think it's unforgivable. She
thinks it's just part of his nasty humor and not that cruel since Hermione
isn't going to die if she comes an hour later to the Infirmary and has to
sit through potions. She pointedly referred to two of my teachers.
I have to confess: That's something they could've said, probably I've gotten
similar comments from then - I try to forget such occasions as fast as
possible.

I think what upsets me about it is not that he comments nastily on her looks
but that she has been obviously affected by a hex and this is one of the
more unforgivable rules to break - but then the students (esp. Slytherins
and Draco) curse each other occasionally in arguments so why am I surprised
he just goes over it as if nothing happened?

Dinah


_________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com